Forty years ago, Alex Ferguson’s departure from Aberdeen to join Manchester United sent shockwaves through the football world. During his eight years with the Dons, Ferguson had secured three league titles, four Scottish Cups, a Cup Winners’ Cup, and the UEFA Super Cup.
One fan expressed their dismay to BBC Scotland News at the time, stating, “I think he’s making the wrong move, I think he will regret it.” Ferguson went on to achieve immense success at Manchester United, winning 38 trophies over 26 years.
On the 40th anniversary of his move, which occurred on November 6, 1986, those involved are reflecting on the events. BBC Scotland football broadcaster Roddy Forsyth was tasked with investigating rumors of Ferguson’s talks with Manchester United. He found Ferguson and Manchester United chairman Martin Edwards at an airport hotel in Aberdeen.
Forsyth recounted overhearing Ferguson and Edwards in the restaurant area and confirming Ferguson’s new role as manager. He shared, “There was Martin Edwards and Alex Ferguson, and I said ‘are you the new manager of Manchester United?’ and he said ‘yes’.” Forsyth then informed his newsroom, with the story leading sports news after the main headlines about the Chinook helicopter disaster in Shetland.
Fans at the time expressed a mix of emotions. One fan believed Ferguson was making a mistake and would regret it, while another felt Ferguson was being hypocritical by leaving after preaching loyalty to his players.
Today, fans have a more measured perspective. Sandy Smith, a lifelong Dons supporter, described the departure as “totally gutting” given the difference between Manchester United and Aberdeen. He acknowledged Ferguson’s initial struggles at Old Trafford but noted his eventual success.
The club also felt the impact. Ian Donald, then vice-chairman, called it a “shattering blow” that happened “virtually overnight.”
Captain Willie Miller described the period as one of “uncertainty” and admitted that players missed the manager despite his temper. He noted that Ferguson’s demanding style, including throwing cups in the dressing room, would not be accepted by modern players.
Ferguson himself stated he left “the most secure job in British football” for the “only club” he ever wanted to join from Aberdeen. With 13 Premier League titles, two Champions League victories, five FA Cups, and four League Cups won at Manchester United, it seems he had no regrets.
